Physics Van 3-site Navigational Menu

Physics Van Navigational Menu

Q & A: Why are protons less massive than neutrons?

Learn more physics!

Most recent answer: 05/05/2010
Q:
Why are protons less massive than neutrons? I tried to work out how much energy it would take to shove an electron charge into a region of diameter d, and I got: U = alpha hbar c / diameter = 197 eV nm / (137 * diameter). I hope that is right. Taking the proton size to be about 1 femtometer, I get U ~ 1.44 Mev ... that is way more than the mass difference between a proton and neutron! And it suggests the proton should be heavier! Don't the quarks have the same color charge in the proton vs. neutron, so they look the "same" according to the nuclear force? So I'd think the only difference could be the electric force. Did I calculate wrong? Either way, I don't understand how the proton can be less massive. Please help satisfy some curiousity here. Thanks!
cheater read wifes who cheat
married men cheat with men open wifes cheat
best android spy spy on mobile how to spy on an android phone
abortion pill clinics abortion pill prices for abortions
finasteride sigridw.com cialis 80mg
finasteride zithromax cialis 80mg
can i take minocycline with birth control can i take minocycline with birth control can i take minocycline with birth control
lisinopril and energy drinks lisinopril and energy drinks lisinopril and energy drinks
lisinopril and energy drinks lisinopril and energy drinks lisinopril and energy drinks
cialis dosage and go cialis dose for copd pts
viagra bestellen online viagra online shop pillen kopen
cialis manufacturer coupon cialis discounts coupons prescription drug coupons
lilly cialis coupon click coupons prescriptions
claritinekombo warpedfish.co.uk claritine za psa
voltaren ára go voltaren
fusidinezuur kopen blog.jp-sa.org fusidic acid
ibuprofen rapid ibuprofen spc ibuprofen
buscopan hund buscopan wirkung buscopan dragees
amlodipine 5 mg amlodipine kat amlodipine accord
voltaren retard voltaren forte voltaren spray
nurofen cold and flu dosage internetsellout.com nurofen plus dosage
nurofen cold and flu dosage internetsellout.com nurofen plus dosage
singulair 4 mg granulat scottdangelo.com singulair patient information
vivitrol alcohol vivitrol implant narcan challenge

- John Marsh (age 20)
Springfield, IL, USA
A:
Your question puzzled physicists for many years.  The answer seems to be that not only is there a difference in the electrostatic energy, but there is a difference in the mass contribution of the internal constituents. According to the quark hypothesis the proton is composed (primarily) of two up quarks and one down quark.  The neutron is composed (primarily) of two down quarks and one up quark.  It is difficult to ascertain exactly the masses of the bound quarks but it seems that the up quark does have a heavier effective mass.  Dick Plano has some more to say about it:


LeeH
why people cheat catch a cheat how many people cheat
married woman looking to cheat My wife cheated on me most women cheat
married men cheat with men why husbands cheat wifes cheat
free prescription cards nwwebdesigns.net walgreens prints coupon codes
married cheaters redsoctober.com dating for married men
discount card prescription site print cvs
rite aid prescription transfer coupon open coupon rite aid
priligy 30mg click cialis 40mg
levaquin pill internetsellout.com furosemide pill
free viagra samples coupon gallaghermalpractice.com viagra 2016 coupon
coupon for viagra viagra trial coupon viagra discount coupons online
manufacturer coupons for prescription drugs online viagra coupons coupon prescription
can i take minocycline with birth control read can i take minocycline with birth control
lisinopril and energy drinks lisinopril and energy drinks lisinopril and energy drinks
cialis dosage and go cialis dose for copd pts
diabetes affect sexuality open diabetes sexuality treatment
acheter viagra pas acheter viagra pas acheter viagra pas
cialis coupon card eblogin.com cialis coupons from manufacturer
coupons for prescriptions mha.dk drug prescription card
claritinekombo read claritine za psa
voltaren ára voltaren duo voltaren
kamagra wikipedia kamagra jelly kamagra shop
sildenafil pfizer link sildenafil sandoz
allods online cwblog.centralworld.co.th allo allo
motilium enceinte site motilium et grossesse
singulair 4 mg granulat scottdangelo.com singulair patient information
prescriptions coupons cialis coupon drug prescription card

(published on 04/19/2010)

Follow-Up #1: dimensional potential energy

Q:
I had never seen that "U = alpha hbar c / diameter" equation before. So I had to work it out to convince myself it is that simple (well, I was off by a factor of 2, but I probably made a little mistake). Is there some reason that this result should be "obvious", say in the order of alpha and then using dimensional analysis to get the rest? It seems "pretty" enough, that it seems this equation should be clearer to me. Any help in gaining physical intuition here would be much appreciated!
why people cheat infidelity signs how many people cheat
cheater click wifes who cheat
married woman looking to cheat go most women cheat
married men cheat with men women that cheat with married men wifes cheat
discount card prescription damske.com print cvs
finasteride lasix 40mg cialis 80mg
ventolin 2mg bistromc.org deltasone 40mg
online discount pharmacy viagra coupons and discounts coupon for prescription
viagra coupons from manufacturer liberitutti.info drug discount coupons
coupons for prescriptions floridafriendlyplants.com prescription drugs discount cards
coupons for prescriptions new prescription coupons prescription drugs discount cards
pfizer coupons for viagra viagra coupon viagra discounts coupons
coupon for viagra open viagra discount coupons online
manufacturer coupons for prescription drugs viagra 2016 coupon coupon prescription
can i take escitalopram in the morning can i take escitalopram in the morning can i take escitalopram in the morning
can i take antabuse and naltrexone can i take antabuse and naltrexone can i take antabuse and naltrexone
lisinopril and bisoprolol lisinopriland.net lisinopril and bisoprolol
cialis dosage and cialis dose for copd pts
diabetes affect sexuality diabetes sexuality treatment
viagra bestellen online viagra pillen kruidvat pillen kopen
cialis coupon lilly blog.nvcoin.com transfer prescription coupon
claritinekombo warpedfish.co.uk claritine za psa
voltaren ára house.raupes.net voltaren
augmentin générique arbot.cz augmentin sirop
naprosyn roche naprosyn wiki naprosyn nedir
arcoxia 30 go arcoxia wiki
fusidinezuur kopen go fusidic acid
ibuprofen rapid tracyawheeler.com ibuprofen
ibuprofen rapid tracyawheeler.com ibuprofen
amlodipine 5 mg amlodipine bijwerkingen amlodipine accord
amlodipine 5 mg amlodipine kat amlodipine accord
singulair 4 mg granulat scottdangelo.com singulair patient information
trental cena link trental nuspojave

- Jack Swanson (age 19)
Chicago, IL, USA
A:
Sure, let's use CGS, in which the potential energy is (dimensionally) just charge2/distance. alpha is defined as q2/hc (I'm not worried about factors of 2π here.), where q is the electron charge.  So the expression you give is just q2/diameter, the potential energy.

Mike W.

The alpha/hbar c  factor is a red herring since this is strictly a classical problem.  The correct classical answer is U =  e2/ 4πεo 3/5a   where a  is the radius, not the diameter.  See http://farside.ph.utexas.edu/teaching/em/lectures/node56.html  for a derivation.

LeeH
why people cheat infidelity signs how many people cheat
best android spy apps to spy on phones how to spy on an android phone
walgreens coupons deals free grocery coupons walgreens photo print coupons
married cheaters redsoctober.com dating for married men
free online coupons onlineseoanalyzer.com new prescription coupons
imitrex 50mg thepoliticalsword.com flagyl 200mg
coupons prescriptions blog.brunothalmann.com manufacturer coupons for prescription drugs
coupons prescriptions blog.brunothalmann.com manufacturer coupons for prescription drugs
discount prescriptions coupons printable cialis coupon internet drug coupons
1 wk pregnant d&c dilation and curettage article on abortion
diabetes affect sexuality diabetes sexuality treatment
lilly cialis coupon click coupons prescriptions
claritinekombo warpedfish.co.uk claritine za psa
naproxennatrium site naproxen migraine
voltaren ára go voltaren
arcoxia 30 click arcoxia wiki
kamagra wikipedia kamagra jelly kamagra shop
flibanserin online click flibanserin buy
buscopan hund buscopan dosierung buscopan dragees
cefdinir red stool ski-club-auringen.de cefdinir nedir
amlodipine 5 mg amlodipine bijwerkingen amlodipine accord
amlodipine 5 mg link amlodipine accord
allods online go allo allo
trental cena trental trental nuspojave
vivitrol alcohol what is vivitrol shot narcan challenge

(published on 05/05/2010)

Follow-up on this answer.