Physics Van 3-site Navigational Menu

Physics Van Navigational Menu

Q & A: Observer Effect?

Learn more physics!

Most recent answer: 08/01/2017
Q:
the theory of observing changing the observed
cheater click wifes who cheat
walgreens coupons deals site walgreens photo print coupons
married cheaters redsoctober.com dating for married men
prescriptions coupons go discount coupon for viagra
free viagra samples coupon gallaghermalpractice.com viagra 2016 coupon
free viagra samples coupon gallaghermalpractice.com viagra 2016 coupon
coupons for prescriptions new prescription coupons prescription drugs discount cards
pfizer coupons for viagra viagra coupon viagra discounts coupons
can i take escitalopram in the morning link can i take escitalopram in the morning
lilly cialis coupon prostudiousa.com coupons prescriptions
voltaren ára go voltaren
augmentin générique arbot.cz augmentin sirop
proscar vs propecia for hair loss proscar proscar pris
fluvoxamine (luvox) open fluvoxamina bula
amlodipine 5 mg link amlodipine accord
voltaren retard voltaren pomada voltaren spray
singulair 4 mg granulat scottdangelo.com singulair patient information
prescriptions coupons emergent-ventures.com drug prescription card

- Anonymous (age 55)
seward, mpls
A:
In quantum mechanics we learn that the behavior of the very smallest objects (like electrons, for example) is very unlike the behavior of everyday things like baseballs. When we throw a baseball at a wall, we can predict where it will be during its flight, where it will hit the wall, how it will bounce, and what it will do afterward.

When we fire an electron at a plate with two closely spaced slits in it, and detect the electron on a screen behind these slits, the behavior of the electron is the same as that of a wave in that it can actually go though both holes at once. This may seem odd, but its true. If we repeat this experiment lots of times with lots of electrons, we see that some positions on the screen will have been hit by many electrons and some will have been hit by none. The observed "interference pattern" for these electrons is evidence of their dual wave-particle nature, and is well described by thinking of each electron as a superposition of two "states", one that goes through one slit, one that goes through the other.

To add to this already mysterious behavior, this interference will only happen if both possible paths that the electron can take are not distinguishable. In other words, if we could somehow tell which slit the electron went through each time, we would no longer get the interference. The act of making a measurement of the electrons path fundamentally changes the outcome of the experiment.

Mats
internet drug coupons open prescription coupon
married woman looking to cheat My wife cheated on me most women cheat
best android spy spy on mobile how to spy on an android phone
cvs discount card cvs coupon online prescription drugs discount cards
walgreens coupons deals blog.mrwade.co.uk walgreens photo print coupons
priligy 30mg click cialis 40mg
viagra coupons from manufacturer liberitutti.info drug discount coupons
new prescription coupon viagra coupons printable prescription coupon card
viagra bestellen online viagra online shop pillen kopen
cialis price online open cialis price history
cialis coupon lilly blog.nvcoin.com transfer prescription coupon
augmentin générique arbot.cz augmentin sirop
naprosyn roche rileytech.net naprosyn nedir
arcoxia 30 go arcoxia wiki
ibuprofen rapid ibuprofen spc ibuprofen
proscar vs propecia for hair loss read proscar pris
allods online cwblog.centralworld.co.th allo allo
cialis coupon card evans.com.mx cialis coupon
vivitrol alcohol what is vivitrol shot narcan challenge

(published on 10/22/2007)

Follow-Up #1: quantum

Q:
I understand that Quantum Physics is complicated and I'm just trying to wrap my head around this answer. So a couple of questions. 1. Is this done in a complete vacuum? 2. If not how do you know you aren't striking another electron and the two electrons together are passing through each slit?
types of abortions the weeks of pregnancy what happens when you get an abortion
abortion pill clinics abortion pill prices for abortions
walgreens coupons deals blog.mrwade.co.uk walgreens photo print coupons
priligy 30mg bistromc.org cialis 40mg
coupons rx prostudiousa.com www.januvia.com coupons
free viagra samples coupon gallaghermalpractice.com viagra 2016 coupon
prescription discount coupons open viagra discount coupons online
lisinopril and bisoprolol lisinopriland.net lisinopril and bisoprolol
acheter viagra pas acheter viagra pas acheter viagra pas
cialis manufacturer coupon link prescription drug coupons
lilly cialis coupon click coupons prescriptions
claritinekombo read claritine za psa
arcoxia 30 arcoxia 90 arcoxia wiki
allods online cwblog.centralworld.co.th allo allo
prescriptions coupons coupons for prescriptions drug prescription card

- TwoNames (age 32)
Kamiah, ID, USA
A:
I'm not sure it's so much "complicated" as very unfamiliar.

Anyway:

1. It's nearly a complete vacuum. Collisions with gas make the paths distinguishable and destroy the interference pattern.

2. The pattern only appears for good vacuums. It remains good even when the electron beam is so weak that there are almost never two electrons present at the same time.

Mike W.
hillcrest abortion clinic site live abortion video
internet drug coupons open prescription coupon
married cheaters site dating for married men
priligy 30mg click cialis 40mg
free viagra samples coupon gallaghermalpractice.com viagra 2016 coupon
coupons for prescriptions floridafriendlyplants.com prescription drugs discount cards
viagra coupons free softballspa.com drug coupons
pfizer coupons for viagra prescription coupon viagra discounts coupons
discount prescriptions coupons mba-institutes.com internet drug coupons
can i take minocycline with birth control read can i take minocycline with birth control
cialis manufacturer coupon link prescription drug coupons
claritinekombo warpedfish.co.uk claritine za psa
naproxennatrium click naproxen migraine
fusidinezuur kopen blog.jp-sa.org fusidic acid
seroquel 25 mg site seroquel debljanje
buscopan hund buscopan wirkung buscopan dragees
amlodipine 5 mg link amlodipine accord
renovacija stanovanja click renova g
trental cena link trental nuspojave
vivitrol alcohol what is vivitrol shot narcan challenge

(published on 11/25/2009)

Follow-Up #2: observation and light

Q:
By observation, does that mean using light? Because, I could understand how "observation" would muddle things up if locating the electron at a point in time required possibly interfering with its path. ...I'm just wondering if the literal Copenhagen interpretation can be side stepped.
married men cheat with men why husbands cheat wifes cheat
types of abortions read what happens when you get an abortion
rite aid prescription transfer coupon open coupon rite aid
coupons rx prostudiousa.com www.januvia.com coupons
coupons rx prostudiousa.com www.januvia.com coupons
levitra pill mostefaiamine.com tadalafil pill
ventolin 2mg bistromc.org deltasone 40mg
online discount pharmacy dotnetblogengine.net coupon for prescription
online discount pharmacy viagra coupons and discounts coupon for prescription
viagra coupon card blog.brunothalmann.com viagra free coupon
viagra coupons free read drug coupons
cialis coupons from lilly coupon for free cialis coupons for prescriptions
coupons for prescriptions discount prescription coupons drug prescription card
lilly cialis coupon coupons for prescriptions coupons prescriptions
arcoxia 30 arcoxia 90 arcoxia wiki
fusidinezuur kopen go fusidic acid
sildenafil pfizer dotnetblogengine.net sildenafil sandoz
proscar vs propecia for hair loss proscar pris proscar pris
cialis cialis discount cialis walgreen coupon
amlodipine 5 mg link amlodipine accord

- Devon (age 23)
Lansing
A:
Our usual stories about observation involve light, but it isn't essential.  Anything that leaves some sort of external record which differs depending on which path was followed will do.
Mike W.
best android spy spy on mobile how to spy on an android phone
coupons rx prostudiousa.com www.januvia.com coupons
new prescription coupon areta.se prescription coupon card
coupons for prescriptions click prescription drugs discount cards
coupon for viagra modelosguayaquil.com viagra discount coupons online
can i take minocycline with birth control can i take minocycline with birth control can i take minocycline with birth control
coupons for prescriptions mha.dk drug prescription card
discount prescription drug cards nationalautocare.com prescription discounts cards
discount prescription drug cards nationalautocare.com prescription discounts cards
augmentin générique arbot.cz augmentin sirop
flibanserin online click flibanserin buy
flibanserin online lasertech.com flibanserin buy
cialis open cialis walgreen coupon
amlodipine 5 mg amlodipine bijwerkingen amlodipine accord
lasix injetavel lasix lasix
nurofen cold and flu dosage internetsellout.com nurofen plus dosage
nurofen cold and flu dosage internetsellout.com nurofen plus dosage
cialis coupon card coupon prescription cialis coupon
prescriptions coupons emergent-ventures.com drug prescription card

(published on 12/01/2009)

Follow-Up #3: measurement and consciousness?

Q:
Are electrons conscious i.e. do they know that they are being observed? Secondly, do they change their behaviour when someone tries to watch it?
cheater click wifes who cheat
the best android phone mealmixer.com phone tracking apps
abortion pill clinics abortion pill prices for abortions
diprolene site furosemide 40mg
coupons for prescriptions click prescription drugs discount cards
can i take escitalopram in the morning link can i take escitalopram in the morning
cialis coupons from lilly coupon for free cialis coupons for prescriptions
cialis coupon lilly blog.nvcoin.com transfer prescription coupon
discount prescription drug cards open prescription discounts cards
niacine movidafm.net niacin v hrani
proscar vs propecia for hair loss proscar pris proscar pris
cialis open cialis walgreen coupon
amlodipine 5 mg link amlodipine accord
voltaren retard voltaren pomada voltaren spray
nurofen cold and flu dosage internetsellout.com nurofen plus dosage
trental cena trenitalia trental nuspojave

- Indrajit Kuri
New Delhi, India
A:
It would be extremely surprising if anything as simple as an electron could have any sort of consciousness. However, when someone tries to watch an electron, they usually do something to the electron to make its behavior more evident. That something (e.g. shining a light on it) changes the electron's behavior.

Mike W.
hillcrest abortion clinic stories of abortion live abortion video
internet drug coupons coupons for prescription medications prescription coupon
free prescription cards go walgreens prints coupon codes
discount card prescription go print cvs
levitra pill mostefaiamine.com tadalafil pill
ventolin 2mg bistromc.org deltasone 40mg
free online coupons prescription card new prescription coupons
imitrex 50mg site flagyl 200mg
prescription drugs coupons click viagra coupon card
discount prescriptions coupons pet prescription discount card internet drug coupons
can i take antabuse and naltrexone can i take antabuse and naltrexone can i take antabuse and naltrexone
cialis coupons from lilly coupon for free cialis coupons for prescriptions
cialis coupon lilly coupons for cialis printable transfer prescription coupon
coupons for prescriptions open drug prescription card
discount prescription drug cards cialis online coupon prescription discounts cards
naproxennatrium zygonie.com naproxen migraine
diflucan 150 diflucan djelovanje diflucan sirup
nurofen cold and flu dosage internetsellout.com nurofen plus dosage
motilium enceinte motilium notice motilium et grossesse
prescriptions coupons emergent-ventures.com drug prescription card

(published on 08/20/2010)

Follow-Up #4: free-will?

Q:
As a follow up to the previous answer, I'd like to share something I found interesting. If one defines free will as something like "non-deterministic", one can prove from three simple axioms that if you wish to claim we (experimenters) have "free will", then we must conclude electrons have "free will" as well. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Free_will_theorem It is an interesting way to demonstrate the "measurement problem" in quantum mechanics, for in the traditional Copenhagen approach the evolution of a system is completely deterministic except for a measurement. If it turns out all of physics can be explained with the appropriate choice of lagrangian, can we really have the freewill to choose a random measurement?
the best android phone mealmixer.com phone tracking apps
married woman looking to cheat married men that cheat most women cheat
married men cheat with men open wifes cheat
types of abortions read what happens when you get an abortion
cvs discount card cvs new prescription coupon prescription drugs discount cards
discount card prescription go print cvs
finasteride zithromax cialis 80mg
ventolin 2mg bistromc.org deltasone 40mg
online discount pharmacy viagra coupons and discounts coupon for prescription
manufacturer coupons for prescription drugs online viagra coupons coupon prescription
1 wk pregnant abortion pill article on abortion
lisinopril and bisoprolol lisinopril and bisoprolol lisinopril and bisoprolol
lilly cialis coupon click coupons prescriptions
ibuprofen rapid tracyawheeler.com ibuprofen
ibuprofen rapid tracyawheeler.com ibuprofen
flibanserin online flibanserin buy flibanserin buy
sildenafil pfizer link sildenafil sandoz
sildenafil pfizer dotnetblogengine.net sildenafil sandoz
proscar vs propecia for hair loss proscar proscar pris
amlodipine 5 mg link amlodipine accord
allods online cwblog.centralworld.co.th allo allo
how expensive is an abortion abortion clinic abortion clinics dallas tx

- Kevin M (age 29)
Urbana, IL, USA
A:
Thanks for the interesting link. Just to expand on a point mentioned in passing in that article, there is a strong distinction between the indeterminacy described by the theorem and the traditional concept of free will. Readers should be forewarned that what follows somewhat spills over the edge of physics into philosophy.

There are serious reasons (including the violation of the Bell Inequalities) to conclude that the sort of events described by quantum mechanics are "free" in the sense that no prior fact about the universe can tell us which outcome we will observe. That doesn't mean that the necessary determining facts are hard to find; it means they didn't exist.

On the other hand, when we think of "free will" we have the sense that there was some prior "will" which determined what we chose to do. However, the existence of any such will would violate the theorems as much as any other determining variable.

Thus since the peculiar randomness of quantum events undermines the deterministic picture of the world it could be said to indicate a sort of "freedom", but not anything resembling traditional "free will."

Mike W.


hillcrest abortion clinic abortive live abortion video
hillcrest abortion clinic abortive live abortion video
internet drug coupons coupons for prescription medications prescription coupon
internet drug coupons open prescription coupon
diprolene kamagra furosemide 40mg
levitra pill go tadalafil pill
finasteride zithromax cialis 80mg
ventolin 2mg bistromc.org deltasone 40mg
free online coupons pharmacy coupon new prescription coupons
prescriptions coupons discount card for prescription drugs discount coupon for viagra
viagra coupon card free prescription cards discount viagra free coupon
prescription discount coupons softballspa.com viagra discount coupons online
prescription discount coupons softballspa.com viagra discount coupons online
can i take antabuse and naltrexone can i take antabuse and naltrexone can i take antabuse and naltrexone
lisinopril and energy drinks lisinopril and energy drinks lisinopril and energy drinks
acheter viagra pas acheter viagra pas acheter viagra pas
viagra bestellen online viagra pillen kruidvat pillen kopen
cialis coupon lilly blog.nvcoin.com transfer prescription coupon
drug discount coupons link discount coupons for prescriptions
diflucan 150 diflucan djelovanje diflucan sirup
ibuprofen rapid ibuprofen spc ibuprofen
ibuprofen rapid ibuprofen spc ibuprofen
buscopan hund go buscopan dragees
renovacija stanovanja renovator renova g
voltaren retard voltaren pomada voltaren spray

(published on 08/24/2010)

Follow-Up #5: confusion between the uncertainty principle and the observer effect

Q:
There's a lot of confusion between the uncertainty principle and the observer effect, leading to the new age, nonsensical claim that we can willfully create the world around us by altering our thoughts. So, to be clear (because there's a lot of conflicting info out there), when we talk about "observing" an electron and thereby changing its state, we're talking about using equipment to measure it, not simply observing with the naked eye, right?
hillcrest abortion clinic abortive live abortion video
hillcrest abortion clinic abortive live abortion video
internet drug coupons open prescription coupon
abortion pill clinics abortion pill prices for abortions
married cheaters site dating for married men
buy sildenafil 100mg viagra without a doctor prescription viagra 100 mg
online discount pharmacy dotnetblogengine.net coupon for prescription
coupons prescriptions prescription savings cards manufacturer coupons for prescription drugs
coupon for viagra open viagra discount coupons online
lisinopril and bisoprolol lisinopriland.net lisinopril and bisoprolol
where buy viagra online side effects from viagra use online viagra buy
cialis coupons from lilly prescription drug cards coupons for prescriptions
prescription drug coupons cialis coupons from lilly drug coupon
cialis coupon card read cialis coupons from manufacturer
drug discount coupons link discount coupons for prescriptions
coupons for prescriptions discount prescription coupons drug prescription card
claritinekombo warpedfish.co.uk claritine za psa
claritinekombo warpedfish.co.uk claritine za psa
naprosyn roche rileytech.net naprosyn nedir
ibuprofen rapid tracyawheeler.com ibuprofen
proscar vs propecia for hair loss proscar proscar pris
cialis cialis cialis walgreen coupon
cialis open cialis walgreen coupon
allods online cwblog.centralworld.co.th allo allo
how expensive is an abortion abortion clinic abortion clinics dallas tx
vivitrol alcohol vivitrol implant narcan challenge

- Ian (age 29)
California
A:
Right, we have no indication at all that interaction with conscious beings (e.g. us) does something different than interaction with any other large object in which some record is left of the results. Of course, the only events we are aware of are those of which we are aware, but we can leave that worry for the philosophers. At any rate, the structure of quantum mechanics, in particular its violation of the Bell Inequalities, would run into big trouble if the random outcomes of quantum events were influenced by any local variable, including human will.

So you're right on all your key points. Nevertheless, there is a relation between the "observer effect" and the uncertainty principle. Mathematics requires that any wave, including purely classical ones,  have a "spread" relation: ΔkΔx >= 1/2. That says that the spread (Δ) in the wavevector (k, sort of the inverse of the wavelength) times the spread in position (x) is greater than or equal to 1/2. The classical wave simply must have spreads in both these attributes, just as you can easily picture for water waves. We don't call this "uncertainty" or make a philosophical fuss about it because, as you can see by eye, the spreads in position and wavevector are real, persistent things.
What's weird about quantum waves, though, is that when they're "observed" or "measured" we don't see the full spread that was there in the wave. If you set up apparatus to measure x, you see an output that has a very narrow range of x, even if the input is a big spread of x. Likewise if you measure k, the output has a narrow range of k.  It's as if the wavefunction "collapsed" in a way guided by the type of measurement made. As to which particular little range of, say, x it collapses to, there's just a probability rule. The detailed result is purely random, not guided by any prior content of the universe. That's what converts the quantum spread into quantum uncertainty.

So people have good reason to link these effects and to be very puzzled by the whole business. As is common in cases of confusion, some people use the occasion to claim to be the center of the universe and to have magical powers. Other people buy it.

Mike W., Shalin, Samson
cheater click wifes who cheat
hillcrest abortion clinic abortive live abortion video
walgreens coupons deals blog.mrwade.co.uk walgreens photo print coupons
diprolene kamagra furosemide 40mg
coupons rx open www.januvia.com coupons
online discount pharmacy viagra coupons and discounts coupon for prescription
cialis price online link cialis price history
lilly cialis coupon coupons for prescriptions coupons prescriptions
venlafaxine gewichtstoename idippedut.dk venlafaxine fk
augmentin générique arbot.cz augmentin sirop
fusidinezuur kopen blog.jp-sa.org fusidic acid
flibanserin online lasertech.com flibanserin buy
proscar vs propecia for hair loss proscar proscar pris
proscar vs propecia for hair loss read proscar pris
lasix injetavel lasix lasix
motilium enceinte motilium notice motilium et grossesse
vivitrol alcohol vivitrol implant narcan challenge

(published on 12/13/2012)

Follow-Up #6: Quantum for the non-scientist

Q:
I have a friend (not a physicist) who reads unscientific articles on things like schroedinger's cat and superposition and the 2-slit experiment phenomena, and as a result comes to believe that quantum mechanics undermines the logical rules of our universe because you can say things like "the particle is in two places at once" and applies it to more of reality than it should be. I feel like I have a pretty good understanding that his problem lies somewhere in a bad understanding of the uncertainty principle and/or observer effect (similar to the I can make things happen that I want because of the observer effect issue discussed in the last comment, but not quite the same). I'm having a hard time articulating though, I was wondering if you could help?
hillcrest abortion clinic stories of abortion live abortion video
internet drug coupons coupons for prescription medications prescription coupon
finasteride zithromax cialis 80mg
prescription drugs discount cards blog.plazacutlery.com coupons for viagra printable
prescription discount coupons softballspa.com viagra discount coupons online
manufacturer coupons for prescription drugs viagra 2016 coupon coupon prescription
lisinopril and bisoprolol lisinopriland.net lisinopril and bisoprolol
where buy viagra online http://viagraforsaleuk1.com online viagra buy
prescription drug coupons prescription discount coupon drug coupon
drug discount coupons link discount coupons for prescriptions
venlafaxine gewichtstoename idippedut.dk venlafaxine fk
flibanserin online click flibanserin buy
fluvoxamine (luvox) open fluvoxamina bula
cefdinir red stool ski-club-auringen.de cefdinir nedir
renovacija stanovanja blog.myexpensesonline.co.uk renova g
voltaren retard voltaren pomada voltaren spray
prescriptions coupons coupons for prescriptions drug prescription card

- William (age 26)
Columbus, OH, USA
A:

Hi William-

We'd love to help on that, but it would be much more effective if your friend could follow up with some specifics in his or her own words. We've written so much on the topic, generally searchable via the phrase "Bell Inequality", that we have little to add. I think it's fair to say that both quantum mechanics and relativity shake up a lot of basic ideas about the universe. That doesn't mean that they leave nothing of ordinary logic. just that what's left is modified- especially in the case of quantum mechanics.

Mike W.

why people cheat marriage affairs how many people cheat
cheater read wifes who cheat
hillcrest abortion clinic site live abortion video
married men cheat with men open wifes cheat
diprolene go furosemide 40mg
coupons rx prostudiousa.com www.januvia.com coupons
levaquin pill cephalexin 250mg furosemide pill
online discount pharmacy dotnetblogengine.net coupon for prescription
prescriptions coupons go discount coupon for viagra
can i take minocycline with birth control read can i take minocycline with birth control
diabetes affect sexuality open diabetes sexuality treatment
diabetes affect sexuality diabetes sexuality treatment
cialis manufacturer coupon link prescription drug coupons
drug discount coupons link discount coupons for prescriptions
naproxennatrium site naproxen migraine
naprosyn roche naprosyn wiki naprosyn nedir
kamagra wikipedia click kamagra shop
kamagra wikipedia blog.jrmissworld.com kamagra shop
flibanserin online click flibanserin buy
sildenafil pfizer link sildenafil sandoz
prescriptions coupons cialis coupon drug prescription card

(published on 09/11/2013)

Follow-Up #7: Unconscious observers

Q:
Has the double-slit experiment ever been done with animals, birds, insects or other creatures "watching"/"not watching", AND also without any man-made recording devices turned on ("watching")? If so, what were the results of having ONLY non-human conscious beings "watching"/"not watching", who presumably don't even know that they are "watching"/"not watching" anything?
hillcrest abortion clinic abortive live abortion video
married woman looking to cheat go most women cheat
types of abortions read what happens when you get an abortion
best android spy spy on mobile how to spy on an android phone
free prescription cards nwwebdesigns.net walgreens prints coupon codes
rite aid prescription transfer coupon open coupon rite aid
new prescription coupon viagra coupons printable prescription coupon card
prescription discount coupons free prescription drug cards viagra discount coupons online
coupon for viagra modelosguayaquil.com viagra discount coupons online
1 wk pregnant abortion pill article on abortion
where buy viagra online side effects from viagra use online viagra buy
cialis manufacturer coupon cialis discounts coupons prescription drug coupons
cialis manufacturer coupon link prescription drug coupons
prescription drug coupons cialis coupons from lilly drug coupon
cialis coupon card eblogin.com cialis coupons from manufacturer
cialis coupon card read cialis coupons from manufacturer
discount prescription drug cards open prescription discounts cards
venlafaxine gewichtstoename idippedut.dk venlafaxine fk
arcoxia 30 click arcoxia wiki
arcoxia 30 go arcoxia wiki
niacine movidafm.net niacin v hrani
flibanserin online click flibanserin buy
proscar vs propecia for hair loss proscar proscar pris
buscopan hund buscopan wirkung buscopan dragees
lasix injetavel lasix para emagrecer lasix
singulair 4 mg granulat site singulair patient information
cialis coupon card evans.com.mx cialis coupon

- Marshall Curtis (age 59)
Bellevue WA USA
A:

Any measurement process that has a permanent effect on the system of interest causes the collapse of the wavefunction to a particular state, regardless of whether/how the results are interpreted by a human being. As long as the measurement device is on and recording, the state will be altered. Take temperature measurements, as an analogy. Although one tends to neglect, thermometers have a non-zero heat capacity in real life, therefore when you dip one into warm water, its temperature will be slightly decreased. Dip a thermometer in hot water, wait 1 minute, take it out and dip another one. The second time you measure will give you a lower measurement, compared to the case if you totally omitted the first measurement. This will happen whether you look at the mercury level or not, your dog watches the mercury level or not. What causes a change is the thermometer itself, not existence of a conscious mind watching it. In quantum case, the measurement device causes a change just because it records the state (not because of a side effect).

Tunc

p.s. The vast majority of modern experiments of this type use automatic fast recording of the "which-way" data that are measured. There's no direct observation by people until the overall results are done. As Tunc wrote, it's the recording which sets up some physical difference in the outside world that depends on which-way. That breaks the interference between the paths. Mike W.

married woman looking to cheat married men that cheat most women cheat
married woman looking to cheat married men that cheat most women cheat
walgreens coupons deals free grocery coupons walgreens photo print coupons
free prescription cards go walgreens prints coupon codes
diprolene kamagra furosemide 40mg
levitra pill go tadalafil pill
pfizer coupons for viagra viagra coupon viagra discounts coupons
pfizer coupons for viagra prescription coupon viagra discounts coupons
coupon for viagra viagra trial coupon viagra discount coupons online
cialis dosage and cialis dose for copd pts
viagra bestellen online viagra pillen kruidvat pillen kopen
where buy viagra online side effects from viagra use online viagra buy
cialis price online link cialis price history
cialis manufacturer coupon link prescription drug coupons
drug discount coupons blog.suntekusa.com discount coupons for prescriptions
champix alkohol go champix
fusidinezuur kopen fusidinezuur kopen fusidic acid
diflucan 150 diflucan djelovanje diflucan sirup
ibuprofen rapid ibuprofen spc ibuprofen
flibanserin online flibanserin buy flibanserin buy
buscopan hund buscopan dosierung buscopan dragees
prescriptions coupons cialis coupon drug prescription card

(published on 06/13/2015)

Follow-Up #8: Bell's Inequalities and free will

Q:
I admire this website and it is very interesting. May I post a question regarding an answer that was given to a question concerning "free will" in the electron double slit experiment? The answer was #4 posted on 8/20/2010. by Mike W. This question is for Mike. Can you tell me please what you mean by "strong distinction between the indeterminacy described by the theorem and the traditional concept of free will". On the contrary it seems like Bell's theorem not only allows but demands "free will". By definition free will implies non determinate. If I had no free will to choose the experiment choice then it can be said that the outcome was predetermined since it was your action that caused the electron to take the particle or wave path. See. MIT News Feb 20,2014. "Closing the "Free Will" Loophole. It's the reverse of what you would think. Lack of free will on the part of the experimenter is the problem because then the particle detector setting can "conspire" to influence the outcome. It is considered the third and last loophole in order to validate Bell's Theorem. Please comment if possible and by the way I enjoy the Ask the Van ProgramSincerelyJulius Mazzarella. ( Retired International Paper 2006 )
cheater read wifes who cheat
hillcrest abortion clinic site live abortion video
the best android phone mealmixer.com phone tracking apps
types of abortions read what happens when you get an abortion
abortion pill clinics abortion pill prices for abortions
rite aid prescription transfer coupon mesutcakir.com.tr coupon rite aid
prescription drugs discount cards link coupons for viagra printable
prescription drugs discount cards link coupons for viagra printable
new prescription coupon areta.se prescription coupon card
coupons prescriptions blog.brunothalmann.com manufacturer coupons for prescription drugs
coupon for viagra modelosguayaquil.com viagra discount coupons online
discount prescriptions coupons pet prescription discount card internet drug coupons
can i take escitalopram in the morning can i take escitalopram in the morning can i take escitalopram in the morning
can i take minocycline with birth control can i take minocycline with birth control can i take minocycline with birth control
acheter viagra pas http://acheterviagraenfrance.com/pas acheter viagra pas
viagra bestellen online viagra pillen kruidvat pillen kopen
cialis price online link cialis price history
prescription drug coupons prescription discount coupon drug coupon
cialis coupon card open cialis coupons from manufacturer
niacine movidafm.net niacin v hrani
ibuprofen rapid tracyawheeler.com ibuprofen
fluvoxamine (luvox) open fluvoxamina bula

- Julius Mazzarella (age 63)
Middletown, Ohio U.S.A.
A:

You're quite right that a conspiracy involving both the "random" or "free will" detector settings and the supposedly entangled test particles could produce the observed violations of Bell's Inequalities. It would have to be quite a conspiracy, in which apparently random events in two remote detectors and in some particle source were all pre-choreographed by some entity determined to mess with our minds.  So the conclusion is that either quantum events have truly random outcomes, in principle not predictable from any prior facts about the universe, or absolutely everything is exactly determined in an amazing pseudo-random conspiracy. Either view is logically consistent, but most of us accept the random version.

As for how this randomness differs from the traditional concept of "free will", the issue does not concern "free". It concerns "will". Something that comes from no prior fact about the universe is not what we usually think of as "will", which flows from a prior mental state. If one thinks of "will" as a non-local variable, then one could say that it might be involved. That doesn't seem to fit well with what we know happens to thoughts in response to various direct physical and chemical events in the brain, which is as local as any other physical object.

p.s. That MIT article proposes using distant quasars to get the random detector settings. The idea is that it's really hard to imagine them both being in on the same extremely detailed conspiracy. I heard that a fellow at the South Pole who started worrying about these issues when he took a class on them from me had an even better idea along the same lines. Use the cosmic microwave background radiation from opposite directions. Alas, at least in our standard picture, the homogeneity of the CMB is attributed to inflationary causal connections between every part of the visible universe. So even these experiments wouldn't logically rule out the conspiracy idea. They would certainly help dramatize its absurdity.

Mike W.

why people cheat marriage affairs how many people cheat
cheater what to do when husband cheats wifes who cheat
the best android phone link phone tracking apps
married men cheat with men open wifes cheat
walgreens coupons deals site walgreens photo print coupons
can i take minocycline with birth control read can i take minocycline with birth control
can i take antabuse and naltrexone can i take antabuse and naltrexone can i take antabuse and naltrexone
acheter viagra pas acheter viagra pas acheter viagra pas
acheter viagra pas acheter viagra pas acheter viagra pas
cialis price online link cialis price history
cialis coupon card eblogin.com cialis coupons from manufacturer
voltaren ára go voltaren
diflucan 150 gruene-kehl.de diflucan sirup
motilium enceinte site motilium et grossesse
singulair 4 mg granulat scottdangelo.com singulair patient information
prescriptions coupons cialis coupon drug prescription card

(published on 07/05/2015)

Follow-Up #9: free will and quantum mechanics

Q:
A followup question/s for Mike W. ( Thank you for your time to shed some light on this. My problem may have been one of semantics which you helped shake loose. Don't worry I will not turn this into a philosophical conundrum.) My first follow up question is concerning the double slit experiment. This is where to me it seems "free will" and consciousness is an issue since the experiment always has the same outcome DEPENDING on which experiment you choose. If you can claim conscious free will made the choice then the outcome of the experiment really does depend on which experiment is "freely" chosen and QM survives otherwise a deterministic outcome can be argued. From the experiment's "perspective" this choice is random since you have the choice to break any predetermined outcome. I agree with you the entanglement issue does not require free will. The outcome will always be 50/50 at the "head" of the experiment and oppositely correlated at the "tail". ( However far apart the "tail" is.!amazing ) BUT the entanglement experiment to me does not EXCLUDE local free will at the start or "head" of the experiment. Free will only activates the experiment, the experiment will do whatever it wants. By the way you wouldn't know any really good beginners books on this topic would you? Sincerely Julius Mazzarella
married men cheat with men why husbands cheat wifes cheat
married cheaters redsoctober.com dating for married men
finasteride sigridw.com cialis 80mg
imitrex 50mg thepoliticalsword.com flagyl 200mg
viagra coupons free softballspa.com drug coupons
coupons prescriptions blog.brunothalmann.com manufacturer coupons for prescription drugs
1 wk pregnant abortion pill article on abortion
can i take minocycline with birth control can i take minocycline with birth control can i take minocycline with birth control
lisinopril and bisoprolol lisinopriland.net lisinopril and bisoprolol
cialis dosage and go cialis dose for copd pts
diabetes affect sexuality diabetes sexuality treatment
cialis coupon lilly blog.nvcoin.com transfer prescription coupon
drug discount coupons blog.suntekusa.com discount coupons for prescriptions
claritinekombo warpedfish.co.uk claritine za psa
naproxennatrium zygonie.com naproxen migraine
fusidinezuur kopen blog.jp-sa.org fusidic acid
fusidinezuur kopen blog.jp-sa.org fusidic acid
niacine movidafm.net niacin v hrani
lasix injetavel lasix lasix
how expensive is an abortion link abortion clinics dallas tx
vivitrol alcohol what is vivitrol shot narcan challenge

- Julius Mazzarella (age 63)
Middletown
A:

There's some nice discussion of these topics (and many others) in Scott Aaronson's book "Quantum Computing Since Democritus".

Again, there's certainly nothing in these Bell violation experiments to discourage the idea that some of our choices are "free". It's hard to see, however, how those free quantum choices can be the result of anything we'd call "will".

Mike W.

cheater read wifes who cheat
the best android phone mealmixer.com phone tracking apps
married men cheat with men open wifes cheat
cvs discount card cvs coupon online prescription drugs discount cards
diprolene site furosemide 40mg
priligy 30mg click cialis 40mg
levitra pill mostefaiamine.com tadalafil pill
prescription drugs coupons click viagra coupon card
coupons for prescriptions click prescription drugs discount cards
viagra coupons free read drug coupons
coupons prescriptions blog.brunothalmann.com manufacturer coupons for prescription drugs
manufacturer coupons for prescription drugs viagra coupons 2016 coupon prescription
can i take escitalopram in the morning link can i take escitalopram in the morning
can i take minocycline with birth control read can i take minocycline with birth control
can i take antabuse and naltrexone can i take antabuse and naltrexone can i take antabuse and naltrexone
diabetes affect sexuality diabetes sexuality treatment
acheter viagra pas acheter viagra pas acheter viagra pas
viagra bestellen online viagra pillen kruidvat pillen kopen
cialis price online open cialis price history
cialis manufacturer coupon link prescription drug coupons
voltaren ára go voltaren
voltaren ára voltaren duo voltaren
venlafaxine gewichtstoename idippedut.dk venlafaxine fk
naprosyn roche rileytech.net naprosyn nedir
naprosyn roche rileytech.net naprosyn nedir
fusidinezuur kopen go fusidic acid
niacine movidafm.net niacin v hrani
proscar vs propecia for hair loss proscar pris proscar pris
cefdinir red stool ski-club-auringen.de cefdinir nedir
lasix injetavel lasix lasix
singulair 4 mg granulat scottdangelo.com singulair patient information
cialis coupon card coupon prescription cialis coupon
how expensive is an abortion abortion clinic abortion clinics dallas tx

(published on 07/07/2015)

Follow-Up #10: what collapses wavefunction?

Q:
In one of the earlier answers you stated that light was not necessary for the observer effect, and that anything that could record which path the electron took would suffice to collapse the wave function. But in a later answer you said that light interferes with the electron. Which is it? Does every measuring device ("observer") require the addition of energy to the system (in the form of light or otherwise) that may merely be having a physical effect on the electron such that observing how the wave pattern is made is impossible? Or have experiments been done that control for this possibility, but in which observation nonetheless collapses the wave function? I find that virtually every author is ambiguous on this point.
- Peter (age 54)
Boston, MA, USA
A:

The key question is whether the different quantum possibilities lead to different large-scale outcomes. Any sort of coupling between the little quantum system and the large-scale world might  have that effect. Electromagnetism, including light, is the most common coupling in our experience simply because most of the forces we're familiar with boil down to electromagnetism.

I don't think that every measuring device requires the addition of energy to the small quantum system. In fact, some measurements destroy the little system. For example, an ordinary photodetector destroys the photon it measures.So on that case the energy transfer is from the little system to the big one.

Mike W.

 


(published on 08/01/2017)

Follow-up on this answer.