Physics Van 3-site Navigational Menu

Physics Van Navigational Menu

Q & A: Freezing water

Learn more physics!

Browse our 6770 answers by or search term

Q:
I was wondering exactly how does water freeze and how added solvents/solutes affect the freezing process.
- Angie (age 14)
JHS , NYC, NY
A:
Hi Angie,

Freezing water is an example of a phase transition -- a change in the physical properties of a substance when the temperature or pressure are changed. Phase transitions are often accompanied by either the absorption or release of thermal energy.

Water molecules have electric dipole moments -- the oxygen atoms are more negatively charged than the hydrogen atoms, and the molecule is in a bent shape, with hydrogen atoms not quite on opposite sides of the oxygen. This means that water molecules strongly attract each other electrostatically (opposite charges attract each other). If there isn't too much random motion of the molecules (that is, the water isn't too hot), then the molecules prefer to line up in an orderly fashion, with the positively-charged part of one molecule next to the negatively-charged part of another molecule and so on, held together in a rigid crystal. If the molecules have more thermal energy, they shake around and break free of their neighbors. They still like to stick to one another, but because they are moving so much, they constantly change their neighbors and bounce off of each other. This is the liquid phase.

Ice is actually less symmetrical than liquid water. In the liquid state, all directions appear the same, and all places in the liquid have the same properties as all others. Not so with ice -- the crystals point in definite directions over long ranges (you may still need a microscope to see them well for a snowflake, for example, but the crystals still are very large compared to the molecular-scale randomness in liquid water). Freezing transitions of substances involve a reduction in their spatial symmetry, or otherwise said, an increase in how orderly the molecules are arranged.

When water freezes, the molecules give up some of their energy to their environment (by conduction or radiation, helped on macroscopic scales by convection, of course) and slow down. They begin to stick to each other, and as permanent bonds form, additional energy is released (it takes energy to pull the molecules apart, and you get the energy back when you let them stick to each other). The amount of energy released is 80 calories per gram of water when it freezes.

A curious thing about water: liquid water with a temperature close to the freezing point is actually more dense than ice, due to the fact that the crystalline arrangement of water molecules in ice is not the closest packing possible because of the shape of the molecules. You can even melt ice under some circumstances by exerting pressure on it. I suppose it also goes in the opposite direction -- water may re-freeze once the pressure is gone. But of course, as always, the 80 calories per gram must be added when the ice melts and removed when it re-freezes.

If you dissolve something in the water then the freezing point of the solution will be lower than for the water alone. Salt can be used to lower the melting point in many practical situations. The reason for this is that the salt, actually, sodium and chloride ions in solution, "gets in the way" of the water's ability to make a nice, orderly crystal, so when the ice crystal forms, almost all the salt gets left behind in the liquid. That means that freezing the water not only lines up the water molecules but also limits the room the salt ions have for moving around. That makes it harder to freeze. Other additions to the water will have a similar effect. You can try experimenting with sugar, for example, to see how the concentration affects the freezing point of water. Some substances won't dissolve in water (like oil) and won't have an effect on the freezing point, although a coating of oil on top of the water may have an effect on the rate at which heat flows into and out of a container of water.

Tom(+mw)

(published on 08/27/06)

Follow-Up #1: Freezing an energy change?

Q:
Is freezing water an energy change? if it is wot energy change is it?
- Anonymous
Australia
A:
The big energy change when water freezes is in the potential energy of interactions between the water molecules. In the ice, the molecules arrange to touch in a way that lowers this energy. In the liquid, the arrangement is less regular and the energy is not lowered as much.

Mike W.

Freezing is a change in the ordering, or structure of the molecules.  An ice crystal has less spatial symmetry (specific crystal axes are defined in space) than water (every direction is as good as every other direction).  There is an energy associated with this transition -- 80 calories per gram of ice are needed to melt ice at 0C at ordinary pressure, and 80 calories per gram of water are given off during the freezing process.

Tom

(published on 08/29/06)

Follow-Up #2: freezing perfume

Q:
what happens when we Freeze the perfume after mixing water, alcohol & fragrance. How the cooling at -4 degree Centigrade help different substances to mix together
- Ali Ashhad (age 61 )
Sharjah , UAE
A:
If you partially freeze an alcohol-water mixture with some organic solutes in it, the ice formed will be almost pure water. The fragrance should concentrate in the liquid, which will have a higher alcohol concentration than the starting solution.

It would be unusual for cooling to "help different substances to mix together". From some other sites, it seems that perhaps the cooling is used to get some impurities to form clusters that can then be filtered out. In effect, it would help separate different substances. However, I'm not familiar with the details of this process.

Mike W.

(published on 07/09/12)

Follow-up on this answer.