Physics Van 3-site Navigational Menu

Physics Van Navigational Menu

Q & A: The four forces

Learn more physics!

Browse our 5920 answers by or search term

Q:
Hi Guys. I am writing an article and was planning to state that all "change" all "movement" can be attributed (at a fundamental level) to the fundamental forces (electro-magnetic, strong and weak nuclear) plus gravity. Essentailly I am looking for confirmation or refutation before I write it. Is this true? From a physics point of view, is anything (from a sub-atomic particle to a blackhole) known to be able to "move" or "change" without being explained in terms of the three fundamental forces or gravity? Thanks, Brian
- Brian (age 29)
Australia
A:
Yup, the strong, weak, electromagnetic and gravitational forces are the big four forces we all know and love. Actually, since the 1960's we've known that the electromagnetic and the weak nuclear force are really different forms of the same force, called the "electroweak" force.

But I must complain a small bit about your choice of words. "Change" and "movement" do not need forces. Newton's first law says that in an inertial reference frame, if an object has no forces acting on it, it will move with constant velocity (that is, with constant speed and direction). You can find a frame of reference moving with an object so that it won't appear to be moving in that frame, but in other frames of reference the object will be moving. Motion really is the rate of change of position, so if you have motion without force, you have change without force.

Forces govern interactions. They cause accelerations, classically, or they define the allowed quantum states quantum-mechanically, or govern scattering. The quantum picture of the three forces (not including gravity) is one of exchange of force-carrying particles. The strong force is mediated by the exchange of gluons, the electroweak force is mediated by the exchange of photons and the weak force carriers W+, W- and Z^0. We're still at a bit of a loss as to how to get gravity to work quantum mechanically.

Tom

Not only can you have change (say relative positions changing) without any forces, you can also have forces without change. For example, the lowest-energy state of an atom is held together by electrical forces (and nuclear ones in the nucleus) but it is unchanging in time. So there's no necessary or sufficient connection between forces and change.

Mike W.

(published on 10/22/2007)

Follow-up on this answer.